Authentic Italian Restaurants in Newcastle

Craving authentic Italian food in Newcastle? You're in luck! Our harbour city is home to a thriving Italian culinary scene where traditional flavours meet modern Australian influence. From family-run trattorias serving generations-old recipes to contemporary eateries putting a modern twist on classics, Newcastle's Italian restaurants offer something for every pasta lover, pizza enthusiast, and flavour aficionado.

Let's explore the best Italian restaurants in Newcastle, where you can experience a true taste of Italy with Australian hospitality.

As you explore central Newcastle in search of the perfect Italian restaurant, the area emerges as a hub for exceptional Italian dining. This area features several standout establishments where you can indulge in everything from rustic pasta dishes to gourmet pizzas topped with fior di latte and cherry tomatoes.

Bella Italia brings the heart of Italy to Newcastle, blending Northern and Southern traditions. Indulge in woodfired pizzas, hearty pastas, and classic desserts like tiramisu – all crafted with fresh local and imported ingredients.

Market St Basement offers a seasonal menu bursting with bold flavours and refined technique. Signature dishes include fried burrata, truffle risotto, and slow-cooked duck, all served in a warm, inviting setting that elevates Italian cuisine.

Casa Nova, located in Honeysuckle, pairs classic Italian fare with stunning waterfront views. Handmade pasta and woodfired pizza headline the menu, alongside fresh seafood, steaks, ribs, burgers, and vegan options – perfect for date nights or celebrations.

Arno Deli is Newcastle’s go-to for Italian-style panini, coffee, wine, and cannoli. Known for its stacked flavours and loyal lunchtime crowd, Arno also offers charcuterie boxes and dessert platters ideal for events or weekend treats.

Osteria Papazzo delivers an intimate, home-style dining experience led by artisan chef Alessandra Papazzo. With a focus on slow cooking and sustainability, pop-up dinners are hosted Thursday to Saturday at Good Brother, with a dedicated venue coming soon.

For pasta enthusiasts, Newcastle offers several Italian restaurants dedicated to the art of fresh pasta and seasonal sauces. From handcrafted ravioli filled with seasonal ingredients to perfectly al dente tagliatelle ready to be tossed in a rich cream sauce or paired with diced tomatoes and fresh herbs, there is a pasta and sauce combination to make you go weak at the knees on your next Newcastle holiday.

Tipsy Italian, Islington serves up generations of family recipes with flair. Highlights include hot honey-drizzled and fig & pancetta pizzas, chicken saltimbocca, baked scallops, and a dedicated vegan menu. Don’t miss the all-you-can-eat pizza and pasta nights on Tuesdays and Wednesdays.

The Italian Corner, Wickham, offers a sensory journey through Italy’s culinary heritage. Signature dishes like slow-cooked lamb shoulder pappardelle and quattro formaggio gnocchi deliver rich, comforting flavours. Crimped pasta ribbons in creamy ricotta, tomato, and meatball sauce evoke the warmth of a family kitchen.

3 Sicilians, Stockton, brings bold Sicilian flavours across the harbour. Start with crumbed green olives, Cozze al Sugo, or the weekly arancini. The pan-fried veal and Mafaldine al Ragu Siciliano are standouts, and the pizza is unforgettable.

Northern Star Cafe, Hamilton, is a beloved local institution with over 70 years of heritage. Choose your pasta and pair it with one of nine OMG sauces. House-made gnocchi, veal parmigiana, Sienna Chicken, and Pizzaiola Prawns showcase Hamilton’s vibrant spirit on an Italian plate.

Humbug, Newcastle, may not be strictly Italian, but its housemade pastas are exceptional. Think agnolotti with caramelised pumpkin, confit tuna carbonara tagliatelle, and rigatoni with braised shortrib and black garlic. Opt for the Feed Me menu for a curated, indulgent experience.

No guide to Italian restaurants in Newcastle would be complete without highlighting the exceptional pizzerias serving authentic wood-fired creations. From Neapolitan-style pizzas with their characteristic puffy, charred edges to Roman-style varieties with thinner, crispier bases, Newcastle's pizza scene rivals some of the best in Australia.

Napoli Centrale, Newcastle, brings the soul of southern Italy to the city with authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas, pasta, salads, and desserts. Watch pizzaioli at work near the oven or dine alfresco with wine and people-watching. Their dough ferments for 48 hours, creating a soft, airy base topped with San Marzano tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella – perfect for beachside picnics.

Bar Sole, Tighes Hill, is known for its generously sized pizzas and relaxed vibe. Highlights include fresh tomato bruschetta, the indulgent Regina with blue cheese and truffle cream, and the spicy Diavola with jalapeños. Beyond pizza, enjoy homemade pasta, calzones, and Nutella or custard-filled cannoli. Don’t miss their lively Pizza & Beats nights.

In Forno, Hamilton, greets guests with the aromas of garlic and tomato. Signature dishes like the mussels hot pot and olive pizza bowl set the tone, but it’s the wood-fired pizzas – Calabrese, Capricciosa, and more—that shine. Rich pappardelle and house-made tiramisu round out the comforting experience.

Parry St Garage, Newcastle West, blends industrial charm with trattoria warmth. Enjoy blistered wood-fired pizzas, fresh tap beers, and a rich menu featuring seafood linguini and lamb pappardelle. It’s a place to gather, celebrate, and savour.

DiRoma Pizzeria, Merewether, specialises in Romana Tonda-style pizza – thin, crisp, and flavourful. Fresh dough is baked daily at 400°C, with classic and gourmet toppings. Their pasta evokes the warmth of a home-cooked Italian meal.

For those seeking Italian food with a modern twist, Newcastle offers several innovative restaurants reinterpreting traditional Italian cuisine. These establishments respect Italian culinary principles while incorporating contemporary techniques, presentation styles, and occasional fusion elements that reflect Australia's multicultural food scene.

Alfie’s Italian, New Lambton, is a moody neighbourhood wine bar offering a fresh take on traditional Italian dining. Handmade pasta, seasonal dishes, and a curated wine list focused on simplicity and quality make it a standout. Banquet menus designed for sharing often sell out thanks to their bold yet balanced flavours. For night owls, Alfie’s Up Late pairs food with music for a vibrant evening.

Emilio’s Ristorante, The Junction, serves recipes inherited, not invented. Each dish is a tribute to tradition, crafted with care and simplicity. The wood-fired pizzas are smoky and crisp, while tender polpette al sugo, golden cauliflower fritters, and rich mains like Osso Bucco and Veal Saltimbocca round out the menu. Pasta lovers will adore the Fettuccine con Gamberi and indulgent Gnocchi Gorgonzola.

Una Volta, now located on Watt Street above Uptowns in Newcastle, channels the charm of small family-run trattorias. This chic, romantic venue offers vibrant Italian cuisine through thoughtfully curated set menus that explore regional flavours and techniques. On Wednesdays and Thursdays, the set menu is also available à la carte.

Lock’s Paddock, Newcastle, is an intimate space honouring European culinary traditions and local heritage. The share-style menu features standout dishes like pork belly with truffle purée, ricotta gnudi, and the iconic Cacio e Pepe tossed in a pecorino wheel.

Jana Restaurant, QT Newcastle, blends Positano charm with Hunter Valley produce. With an open kitchen and striking design, it offers dishes like Squid Ink Tagliolini, Pork Cotoletta, and lighter bites such as Spring Bay Mussel Soup and Vitello Tonnato.

Newcastle's Italian restaurant scene has deep roots, with several establishments serving the community for decades. These historic eateries offer not just meals but a connection to Newcastle's multicultural heritage. With recipes passed down through generations, these restaurants provide some of the most authentic Italian food experiences in the region.

Sapori at Tailors in Islington is where the essence of Roma is deliciously served in the form of handmade pasta, indulgent desserts, and pizzas divided into Le Rosse (tomato base) and Le Bianche (mozzarella base). A standout is the sentimental Pizza Rocco, named after Francesca’s father, featuring salami, fried onion, ‘nduja, olives, and chilli – a heartfelt tribute made with passion.

The Etna on Darby, Cooks Hill, offers generous portions, bold flavours, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether dining in or grabbing takeaway, guests enjoy Italian classics like fresh seafood, handmade pasta, and pizzas such as the fiery Diavola and robust Sicilian. Signature veal and chicken scallopine dishes come with decadent sauces, and gluten-free pasta ensures everyone can indulge.

Don Beppino’s Trattoria, Merewether, is a beloved Newcastle institution established in 1973 by Sicilian artist Guiessepe Riscato. Now led by Jacqueline Masia, the trattoria honours tradition with handmade sauces and regional pasta recipes inspired by Sardinian heritage, using fresh local produce and imported ingredients.

Rosina’s Pizza Restaurant, Newcastle, is a warm-hearted family affair radiating charm and good humour. Known for authentic pizzas, rich pastas, and comforting stews, highlights include crumbed veal and pepper steak, casual Italian dining at its finest.

The Umbrian Café brings a slice of Italy to Newcastle with rich coffee, handmade piadini, and sweets. Their gnocchi-making nights, complete with antipasti and dessert, offer a hands-on taste of Italian hospitality.

What sets these established restaurants apart is their commitment to traditional cooking methods. From slow-simmered Bolognese sauce to hand-stretched pizza dough, these kitchens maintain the artisanal approaches that make Italian cuisine special. Many offer regional specialties rarely found elsewhere in Newcastle, making them worth seeking out for a truly authentic experience.

Whether you're looking for a quick pizza, a romantic pasta dinner, or a full Italian feast, Newcastle's Italian restaurants offer authentic experiences to satisfy every craving. From traditional family recipes to modern interpretations, our city's Italian food scene continues to evolve while honouring the culinary traditions that make Italian cuisine beloved worldwide.

Did we miss your favourite? Let us know: [email protected]